A Product Manager's Insights in Newsletter Creation

From MVP to Must-Read: Strategies for Sustainable Growth and Iterative Development

As a writer venturing into the world of newsletters, you're not just crafting words — you're creating a product that delivers value to your readers.

This perspective doesn't diminish the artistry of writing — rather, it enhances it by adding purposeful direction and reader-focused intent.

By adopting elements of product thinking, you can transform your newsletter from a simple collection of essays into a dynamic, evolving asset that grows with your audience.

---

Whether you're a seasoned writer, a product manager, a tech enthusiast, or a subject matter expert, mastering newsletter creation can significantly empower your voice and personal brand. By the end of this article, you'll have actionable insights to:

• Launch your newsletter concept using MVP principles and find your unique Ikigai

• Develop a sustainable content strategy that balances your passions with audience needs

• Implement effective feedback mechanisms to continuously improve your offering

• Create a powerful personal brand through authentic, value-driven content

• Build a community around your expertise while maintaining independence from algorithmic constraints

---

Beyond the Void — Created with Dall-E

---

1. Introduction: The Newsletter as a Product - A Mindset for All Writers

As a writer, reimagining your newsletter as a product can revolutionize your approach to audience engagement and value creation. This product-centric mindset empowers you to develop a more impactful, reader-focused offering while building a sustainable practice.

Here's how to apply this approach:

1. Start with an MVP (Minimum Viable Product)

Begin your journey by launching a basic version of your newsletter. This Minimum Viable Product allows you to gather early feedback, define core content types, and quickly iterate based on reader responses.

2. Find Your Audience Fit

Discover your unique value proposition by experimenting with content, format, and tone with an Audience-First Approach. Implement feedback loops through surveys or comment call-to-actions to shape a newsletter that resonates deeply with your target readers.

3. Measure What Matters

Focus on engagement metrics rather than vanity metrics like subscriber counts. Track open rates, click-through rates, and qualitative feedback to gain insights into the actual value you're delivering and inform future content decisions.

4. Develop a Sustainable Strategy

Balance your passions with audience needs in your content mix. Create a content calendar that alternates between topics you love and those your audience demands, reassessing this balance quarterly to ensure long-term viability and prevent burnout.

5. Approach Each Post as a Multi-Faceted Project

Set goals not just for writing, but for design, marketing, and community engagement. This multi-faceted approach transforms you into a well-rounded creator, enhancing the overall quality of your newsletter.

6. Embrace Continuous Improvement

Treat your newsletter as a living product requiring ongoing refinement. Each issue is an opportunity to iterate through the Build-Measure-Learn cycle: release content, measure response, learn from the data, and refine your approach.

The Build-Measure-Learn Cycle: From Idea → Product → Data → New Idea (Source)

The hardest part is often writing into the void in the early stages. However, by treating your newsletter as a product, you're building a valuable asset that can grow, evolve, and potentially become a sustainable business venture. This approach enables you to create consistently valuable content, build loyal readership, and develop a distinct voice in a crowded digital landscape.

As you develop your newsletter, you're also honing valuable skills in content strategy, audience engagement, and data-driven decision making. Each iteration brings you closer to finding your newsletter's unique Ikigai—the sweet spot where your passion, skills, audience needs, and potential for profit intersect.

---

2. Sustainable Development: Finding Your Newsletter's Ikigai

The Ikigai Concept: Visualising the Intersections of Passion, Mission, Profession, and Vocation (Source)

The Japanese concept of Ikigai can help you create a newsletter that's both personally fulfilling and commercially viable. Here's how to apply Ikigai to your newsletter:

1. Identify Your Passion (What you LOVE)

• Brainstorm topics you're passionate about and can write consistently

• Rank ideas based on your enthusiasm and depth of knowledge

2. Define Your Mission (What the world NEEDS)

• Research existing newsletters in your niche to understand audience values

• Engage in community discussions to identify prevalent pain points

• Learn about problems from your target audience

3. Leverage Your Expertise (What you are GOOD AT)

• Audit your professional and personal experiences

• Identify transferable skills that enhance your content

• Consider how your unique perspective offers fresh insights

4. Plan for Profitability (What you can be PAID FOR)

• Research monetization models (subscriptions, sponsorships, products/services)

• Choose a model aligning with your goals and audience expectations

By integrating all four elements of Ikigai, you create a newsletter that's not just sustainable, but poised for growth. Remember, finding your perfect Ikigai is an iterative process – be prepared to adjust and evolve as you and your audience grow together.

---

Understanding Signals and Taking Action

As you implement the Ikigai framework, you'll notice signals indicating how well your newsletter aligns with each aspect. These signals are invaluable feedback mechanisms guiding your ongoing refinement. Here's how to interpret and act on them:

1. Passion + Mission Alignment Signal: High engagement, positive feedback, financial struggles

   • Actions:

     • Explore monetization strategies aligned with your content

     • Consider introducing premium offerings

     • Analyze your audience's willingness to pay

2. Mission + Profession Alignment Signal: Steady income, growth, but feeling uninspired

   • Actions:

     • Incorporate more personal interests into your content

     • Experiment with new content formats that excite you

     • Consider collaborations to inject fresh perspectives

3. Profession + Vocation Alignment Signal: Earning potential, leveraging skills, but low engagement

   • Actions:

     • Conduct reader surveys to understand unmet needs

     • Analyze popular content in your niche

     • Adjust your content to better address audience pain points

4. Vocation + Passion Alignment Signal: Enjoying the process, showcasing expertise, but struggling to grow

   • Actions:

     • Research market trends and audience demographics

     • Develop a clearer value proposition

     • Explore various monetization models suitable for your audience goals

Your newsletter will continuously evolve as you recognize these signals and implement changes. Embrace this iterative approach – it's at the heart of successful newsletter development.

💡 Key Takeaway: Achieving Ikigai alignment is a continuous process. By attentively reading the signals your newsletter provides and taking targeted action, you can refine your offering over time. This approach ensures your newsletter remains personally rewarding, meets market needs, achieves financial goals, and grows sustainably.

---

3. Audience-Driven Iteration: Tuning Into Your Readers' Feedback Signals

Finding your audience is like fishing in a vast, ever-changing ocean. Each newsletter you publish is like casting a line with a carefully chosen bait. Sometimes you’ll reel in nothing but a few nibbles, other times you might catch a message in a bottle with valuable feedback, and on rare occasions, you’ll land a treasure chest.

Even if some casts come up empty, every attempt adds to your understanding of the waters you're navigating. Over time, each post increases your Luck Surface Area, gradually enhancing your chances of connecting with your true audience. This process isn’t just about finding the right bait but also about learning the currents, adjusting your approach, and refining your strategy with each new cast.

Your readers are your North Star, their engagement guiding your content strategy through the vast sea of potential topics. To serve your audience, it's essential to master the art of interpreting and acting on their feedback. Here’s how:

1. Establish Clear Feedback Channels:

   • Set up a dedicated email for reader responses

   • Implement one-click surveys or call to actions for feedback at the end of each newsletter

   • Use social media polls for quick opinions

2. Dive into the Metrics:

   • Open Rates: Which subject lines are catching your readers' eyes?

   • Click-Through Rates: What topics are truly engaging your audience?

   • Reply Sentiment: What nuanced insights do direct responses offer?

3. Take Action:

   • Set a consistent cadence (e.g., monthly) to review metrics and feedback

   • Identify top-performing topics and formats

   • Experiment with new content based on reader interests

   • Gradually adjust your content mix according to engagement trends

Transform your newsletter from a broadcast to a thriving community by closing the feedback loop and embracing co-creation. Use your platform to forge meaningful connections through depth and engagement.

Delve into topics, share personal insights, and ask thought-provoking questions. Highlight reader successes, create discussion prompts, and incorporate interactive elements like virtual events or Q&A sessions, if comfortable. This two-way exchange helps both you and your audience grow together.

At its core, your newsletter is a platform for valuable insights. By consistently delivering depth and resonance, you inspire readers to share your content, leading to organic growth grounded in genuine value.

💡 Key Takeaway: Reader engagement is your guiding compass. By systematically collecting, analyzing, and acting on audience signals, you create a dynamic, reader-centric publication that strengthens with each iteration.

---

4. From MVP to Maturity: Scaling Your Newsletter

As your newsletter transitions from its Minimum Viable Product (MVP) stage and secures audience fit, pivotal decisions about growth, monetization, and scaling emerge. This phase is about amplifying value and monetizing in ways that resonate with both your objectives and your audience's needs. Embracing a product management mindset is crucial here, tailoring strategies to your specific audience and niche.

---

Embracing Independence

One of the standout advantages of newsletters is their freedom from algorithmic constraints. Unlike social media platforms, newsletters empower you to cultivate direct, authentic relationships with your audience. To harness this independence:

• Build and Nurture Your Email List: Focus on growing a robust and engaged subscriber base.

• Reduce Dependence on Third-Party Platforms: Limit reliance on external platforms that might dictate content visibility.

• Maintain Control Over Content and Relationships: Ensure ownership of your content and direct communication channels with your readers.

While it's essential to cherish this independence, leveraging existing platforms can amplify your reach, especially if you already have an established audience on them. Utilize channels like Substack Notes, X, LinkedIn, or Threads as supplementary marketing tools, directing algorithmically curated traffic to your owned mailing list platform.

---

Case Study: The Hustle

The Hustle, a business and tech newsletter, exemplifies successful scaling:

• 2016: Launched as a straightforward daily email. Delivering high-value business news and insights with an engaging, conversational tone. It quickly gained traction, reaching 100,000 subscribers within its first year.

• 2019: Expanded to over 1 million subscribers. Introduced a premium subscription service to diversify revenue that helped entrepreneurs identify business opportunities named Trends.

• 2021: Acquired by HubSpot for a reported $27 million, with nearly 2 million subscribers.

---

Diversification Opportunities

As your newsletter flourishes, diversifying offerings can deepen audience engagement and enhance value. Consider these strategies, and how they align to your niche:

• Develop Complementary Products: Transform your expertise into online courses or branded merchandise

• Explore Content Licensing: Syndicate your content to larger publications or create white-label versions for corporate clients

• Host Events: Foster community through annual conferences or skill-focused workshops

• Build Software Tools: Offer niche-specific apps or productivity templates to assist readers in applying your insights

• Offer Premium Content Tiers: Provide exclusive, high-value content like in-depth research reports for your most engaged readers

• Launch Multimedia Content: Expand into podcasts or video series to cater to varied learning preferences

• Create a Curated Marketplace: Present a selection of products or services aligned with your newsletter's focus

Each new venture should seamlessly align with your newsletter's core mission, delivering comprehensive value while solidifying your authority in the niche.

Throughout this scaling journey, place your readers at the forefront of every decision. Your authentic voice and unwavering commitment to value have been your pillars—ensure they remain as you evolve.

💡 Key Takeaway: Scaling your newsletter demands a balance between independence and strategic growth. By prioritizing direct audience relationships, upholding quality, building a robust brand, and exploring diversification — all while keeping reader value central — you can elevate your MVP into a mature, thriving newsletter enterprise.

---

5. Conclusion: Evolving with Your Newsletter

Starting a newsletter is more than just a writing project—it's about building a product, fostering a community, and potentially launching a business. By applying product management principles, you set the stage for long-term success and personal growth.

Remember, every notable figure in tech, writing, and blogging began where you are now. They chose to create, and they persevered. This journey is about discovering your Ikigai.

Embrace the dual role of both creator and product manager, your authentic voice and unique insights are your greatest assets. Continuously refine your content, listen to your readers, and adapt to the evolving landscape. Keep iterating, learning, and enjoying the journey.

---

Thanks for reading!—Found value in this? Three ways to help:

1. Like, Comment, and Share—Help increase the reach of these ideas

2. Subscribe for free—Join our community of makers

3. Become a paid subscriber—Support this creative journey

Keep Iterating,
—Rohan

→ Connect with me on LinkedIn, Bluesky, Threads, or X.