Escaping the Attention Trap
Understanding the Dominance of Low-Value Social Media Content and How to Change It
Social media platforms are inundated with low-value content, trapping users in an endless scroll of mediocrity that negatively impacts us on both an individual and societal level. This post delves into the reasons behind this trend and explores how we can enhance content quality and foster deeper engagement for a better digital future.
Sections Covered:
Understanding the Attention Economy
The Trap of Predictable Content
Algorithmic Control and Content Visibility
Enhancing Content Quality and Engagement
Read Time: ~ 7 Minutes
Understanding the Attention Economy
Social media platforms generate the majority of their revenue by capturing our attention and selling it to advertisers. By understanding our interests, demographics, and behaviors, they turn our online habits and digital footprints into profit. These platforms don't just display ads, they predict our next moves to create highly targeted markets, ensuring advertisers get the most out of their investment.
“This is what every business has always dreamt of: to have a guarantee that if it places an ad, it will be successful. That’s their [social media companies’] business. They sell certainty.”
— Shoshana Zuboff, professor and author of The Age of Surveillance Capitalism in the Netflix Documentary: The Social Dilemma
For instance, Meta generated 98% of its $135 billion revenue in 2023 from advertising. Similarly, Google, although more diversified, earned 77.8% of its $306 billion revenue in 2023 from advertising.
By collecting vast amounts of data, these companies create detailed user profiles for precise ad targeting. Platforms like Meta’s provide tools that estimate audience sizes based on selected criteria across their product offering, helping advertisers segment populations and scale access according to campaign budgets. This data-driven approach maximizes ad spend efficiency, ensuring ads reach the right people.
The Social Media Marketing Funnel visualizes the stages a user goes through when interacting with content:
Awareness: At the top, content aims to capture attention with short, engaging pieces designed to generate curiosity.
Interest: Content becomes more detailed, fostering genuine interest and engagement through richer content like blog posts, videos, or infographics.
Conversion: The goal is to turn interest into action by providing high-value content such as detailed articles, product demonstrations, and compelling calls to action that persuade users to take the next step.
Loyalty: At the bottom, the focus is on retaining users by consistently providing valuable content to build a loyal audience.
With unprecedented access to such large and targeted audiences, companies can generate short-term revenue through audience churn by focusing on the higher levels of the marketing funnel. Metrics like Serviceable Obtainable Market (SOM) help estimate the realistic, achievable revenue potential from a product or service, enabling companies to prioritize quantity over quality in their strategy. This targeted marketing approach ensures profitability, even with limited campaigns. As a result, the loyalty step is often skipped, rushing users through the first three levels of the funnel repeatedly.
The Trap of Predictable Content
Originality is risky, especially for advertisers, and is at odds with the incentives and machine designed to create certainty. Advertisers demand consistency, which stifles creative experimentation and leads to homogenized content. Creators, reliant on sponsorships, often trade novelty for security to meet these demands.
Predictable content is designed to meet advertiser demands and algorithmic favorability, prioritizing clicks, views, and engagement over originality and depth. This cycle is reinforced by algorithms that promote similar content, creating echo chambers of predictability.
Creators need to invest significant effort into high-quality pieces, making it riskier if they don't pay off. For example, a brief reel might spark initial interest, but an in-depth video or article builds a deeper connection. Yet, if richer content doesn't adhere to predictable formats, it risks being sidelined by algorithms and advertisers, and so must fit predictable patterns to remain visible and monetizable.
Creators are often tempted to rely on higher-churn, lower-value content for quick views. However, it's the deeper, more meaningful content that builds lasting relationships with audiences. Navigating this balance requires careful consideration to avoid sacrificing long-term loyalty for short-term gains.
The pressure to conform leads to a digital landscape where unique, creative, and positively impactful content is rare. Deviating from the norm can threaten creators' income from sponsorships and ad revenue, discouraging originality and reinforcing a cycle of safe, predictable content.
Algorithmic Control and Content Visibility
To further understand the pitfalls of predictability, it's essential to recognize how algorithms reinforce this cycle. Algorithms wield significant power over content visibility. Once a user is profiled, their experience is shaped by opaque algorithms designed to maximize engagement and ad revenue. These algorithms serve as gatekeepers, determining which content generates the most profit for the platform.
Algorithms prioritize content that drives engagement, ensuring users stay on the platform longer, thus increasing exposure to targeted advertisements and boosting revenue. This mechanism directly supports the attention revenue model, where higher user engagement leads to greater ad revenue.
Insights from the release of some of Twitter's source code since Elon Musk's takeover (now X) revealed how these incentives align. Analysis of Twitter's algorithm parameters, summarized in an X thread by
, highlights how the algorithm systematically prioritizes certain types of content to maximize engagement. This underscores the significant control algorithms have over content visibility. While some level of algorithmic curation is inevitable due to the sheer volume of content, the opacity of these mechanisms allows technology companies to act as gatekeepers to culture, often promoting content that aligns with their commercial interests over content that might be more diverse or valuable.For a more equitable and diverse digital landscape, more transparency and control over algorithms are crucial. Users and creators need to understand how algorithms work and have some control over their digital experiences. Greater transparency would enable users to make informed decisions about the content they consume and support.
Enhancing Content Quality and Engagement
To foster innovation, engagement, and sustainability in media, creators must shift their focus towards more meaningful content. As
wrote in his recent post, The two futures of media, “Technology is driving the cost of content creation toward zero, and we are now reckoning with media abundance.” This abundance results in the mass production of superficially compelling content that acts like a drug for our brains, engaging us by preying on emotional responses such as fear and anger. Instead, we need content that is deeply engaging and leaves a positive impact on the consumer, helping to make the world a better place through positive impressionism.To break free from the cycle of predictability, creators can explore new media platforms that prioritize meaningful engagement over the superficial. For example, Substack offers an alternative subscription monetization model through its primary product of direct and unadulterated newsletters. It also has a secondary product, Substack Notes, which can be viewed as an optional algorithmic component to boost engagement for the primary product without affecting its integrity. This approach contrasts sharply with platforms like Instagram and TikTok, whose primary products rely heavily on black-box algorithms for distribution. Embracing platforms with innovative monetization models can foster creativity and diversify content, reducing reliance on predictable, low-risk formats driven by the attention economy.
To create a healthier and more diverse digital landscape, both creators and audiences can take the following steps:
Self-Reflection: Continuously assess the value of the content you create or consume. Ask: Is this helpful? What have I learned? Do I want more of this? Has it positively impacted me? This self-awareness helps prioritize meaningful content.
Support New Models: Embrace platforms with innovative monetization models, such as subscriptions and memberships. These models encourage direct relationships between creators and audiences, fostering a sustainable content ecosystem.
Rich Content Formats: Focus on in-depth formats like YouTube videos, podcasts, and blogs. These formats allow for deep dives into topics, connect with niche audiences, and gradually bring awareness to under-appreciated areas.
Educational Content: Create and support content that educates and informs. This type of content leaves a positive and lasting impact on consumers and contributes to societal benefit.
Community Building: Actively participate in comments, social media interactions, and forums. Building a supportive and engaged community enhances content quality through valuable feedback and shared insights.
Transparency and Fairness: Push for algorithmic transparency and platform features that prioritize quality content and ensure fair compensation for creators. This advocacy helps maintain a balanced and equitable digital environment.
Collective Action: Work together to advocate for better platform policies, amplifying voices and driving meaningful change.
By focusing on these steps, creators and audiences can transform the challenges of the attention economy into opportunities for growth, ushering in a new and better era of social media.
If you found this post thought-provoking, please hit that ❤️ button or share it with someone who might appreciate it.
To stay up to date with the latest posts, be sure to subscribe using the button below.
I’d love to hear your thoughts on this piece. Leave a comment or reach out to me directly on LinkedIn, or at rohan@productartistry.com.
Thank you for reading!
— Rohan
